A Little (Big) Bite out of New York

Posted May 13, 2015 by Stephanie
i am a food blog eats nyc -

i am a food blog eats nyc - i am a food blog eats nyc -

i am a food blog eats nyc - i am a food blog eats nyc -

i am a food blog eats nyc - i am a food blog eats nyc -

i am a food blog eats nyc -

i am a food blog eats nyc - i am a food blog eats nyc -

Mike and I have been back from NYC for a couple of days now and I’ve got to say, as much as the city was a ton of fun, I’m happy to be home. My tummy is happy to be home too – I think I stuffed it past the point of reason! We walked everywhere (even across the Williamsburg Bridge a couple of times), visited a couple of our old haunts and even found some new favorites.

Shake Shack
A Shake Shack burger, the first time you have one, is indescribable. The char on the patty, the squish of the yellow Martin’s potato roll, the addictiveness of the Shack Sauce. The thing about the Shack though, is that it’s incredibly inconsistent. They’ve expanded rapidly and it shows. Sometimes the crinkle cut fries are crispy, sometimes not. Sometimes the patties are charred and pink in the middle, sometimes they’re overcooked and strangely lacking a good crust. I still stand by the fact that Shake Shack has upped the burger game. If, after renovations, the original Madison Square location is just as good as it used to be, I’ll be a loyal fan. Plus, the crinkle cut fries get me every time. I love a good crinkle cut!

I went to RedFarm with a girlfriend and it was hands-down, one of the most fun nights I had in NYC. We got to the restaurant by train line and it was super easy to find. We had the shrimp stuffed crispy boneless chicken wings, pan-fried pork buns, and a peking duck. The duck was a special from Decoy, their duck based sister restaurant downstairs. It was pretty darn delicious. The duck skin was a burnished, deep dark mahogany, crispy and full of flavor, the pancakes were thin, and it came with three different sauces for you to mix and match at your pleasure. The pan-fried pork buns were good too!

Mike and I stopped in for a quick takeout meatball parm and I was utterly delighted. The meatball was giant, tender and nicely flavored, the cheese was hot and gooey, and tomato sauce was rich and plentiful without being too saucy. Surprisingly it wasn’t that messy to eat, which is always a plus in my books. Parm is supposed to be an old school style casual place with classic, well done Italian American food and I think it hits all the right spots for quick and easy eats.

Arrogant Swine
This bbq joint is located in the depths of Brooklyn. It’s not in Williamsburg, or even Green Point – no, Arrogant Swine is in the industrial part of Bushwick, neighbor to corn chip factories and plastic bag manufacturers. It’s a North Carolina style whole hog joint that serves up all it’s sides in waffle format. The waffled cornbread was crisp and sweet and the mac and cheese waffle was everything I dreamed it would be. It was a trek, but it was fun trying out whole hog style bbq. It kind of got me itching to visit the serious bbq joints down South.

Chalait and Big Gay Ice Cream
I was so happy that Izy agreed to meet me at Chalait, a cute light-filled little spot that’s on the cozy side. I ordered a matcha latte and avocado toast. It was a lovely spot to chat in. And bonus, a couple of doors down is Big Gay Ice Cream. Of course we stopped in to get our ice cream on. I’m always super indecisive when ice cream places have big menus, but Big Gay Ice Cream is known for their Salty Pimps, so thankfully it was a no-brainer. I loved it! Creamy vanilla soft serve, dulce de leche, chocolate dip, and a generous sprinkle of sea salt.

Dough Doughnuts and Doughnut Plant
I picked up a lemon poppy seed doughnut from Dough and I wasn’t disappointed. Light, fluffy, and chewy with a lot of lemon flavor and delightfully crunchy poppy seeds. But, if I had to choose between the lemon poppy seed from Dough and the creme brûlée doughnut from Doughnut Plant, the creme brûlée doughnut wins. It’s filled with actual creme brûlée and the top is torched to boot.

If you’re in NYC on the weekend, I’d definitely recommend checking out Smorgasburg. If you’ve ever been to night markets in Asia, you’ve got the right idea: Smorgasburg is basically a big outdoor food court with a beer garden on the side. A lot of popular NYC vendors were there and I enjoyed walking around and seeing what everyone was lining up for. The ramen burger is still super popular, as were giant ribs. I really wanted to try the Scotch eggs, but the lines were kind of insane so we only ended up eating deep-fried cheese curds. Despite the crowd, it was still a super-fun experience. Definitely one of the better food truck gatherings I’ve been to.

Ramen Lab
Ramen Lab is where the makers of Sun Noodles (arguably the most popular manufactured ramen noodle in the States) run an experimental kitchen. Different chefs are rotated through and given a chance to run a pop-up ramen shop. The week we were there was the last week of an incredibly delicious vegetarian XO miso ramen. It was one of the best bowls I’ve had outside of Japan: thick, rich, and full of umami. The noodles were perfectly chewy and well suited to the oolong tea-miso broth. It was a good bowl.

Dominique Ansel Kitchen + Cronuts
When I was in NYC, Dominique Ansel Kitchen just opened up so I dragged Mike along with me to try out the matcha beignets. I was excited, but ultimately disappointed. The beignets themselves were hot and hollow (they’re made to order), but the matcha on top seemed like an afterthought, just dusted on with wanton abandon. We ended up abandoning the bunch. To be honest, I am going to put myself out on a limb here and say that I’m not the biggest fan of Mr. Ansel. I managed to preorder some cronuts and, in a similar vein to the beignets, I was disappointed. It’s probable that I built them up in my mind. They were good, but they weren’t mind-blowing.

Victory Garden and Morgenstern’s
It was hot while we were visiting and hot weather plus vacation is an excuse to step into every frozen treat place there is. Victory Garden and Morgenstern’s were two that stood out. Victory Garden serves up fresh goat milk soft serve with daily flavors. I had the halvah which was creamy, cool, and delicious. I love the texture of a good soft serve and Victory Garden didn’t disappoint. Morgenstern’s was good too: I had a scoop of the green tea pistachio on a sugar cone. The green tea flavor wasn’t super prominent, but I loved the crunch of the whole pistachios.

We went to a bunch of other places too (Russ and Daughters was superb!), but this was getting a little long as is. If you made it through, you’re a trooper! Have a virtual meatball parm, on me!

Until next time NYC!

i am a food blog eats nyc -


  1. Loved hearing about your trip! Would have to second your thoughts on Shake Shack and Doughnut Plant- my burger was great but my mom’s was subpar, and I still rave about the creme brulee doughseed I had four years ago.

  2. keren says:

    great post! just what i needed…i’m visiting NY in september
    i see you went to Russ & Daughters too
    what other places do you recommend?


  3. Gaby says:

    Love this post! Great pictures!

  4. Well it sounds like you guys had a TERRIBLE time! Haha :-) Smorgasburg is one of my favs. I’ll have to add some of these to my list for the next time I’m in NYC.

  5. Yay! You look like you hit some good spots in NYC — I love how honest you are in your reviews too! As much as I love Shake Shack, I’ve also found it to be wayyyy inconsistent between locations. And ditto about Dominique Ansel. I’ve never had the cronut (way too long of a wait, and I don’t have my shit together enough to pre-order it), but I did get the magic souffle thingie where a chocolate souffle is baked inside an orange brioche. It tasted like undercooked bread. There, I said it.

  6. Thanks for sharing where you ate on your trip! Shake Shack will always and forever be one of my favorite burger places. Doughnut Plant and Parm on my next “must-eat” list for NYC. Have you had the chocolate chip and walnut cookies at Levain? You should try them next time!

  7. Jamie says:

    This is an awesome list! My boyfriend and I are visiting NYC for the next few weeks and will definitely have to hit up some of these places. Thanks for the recommendations!

  8. I like Doughnut Plant over Dough too, I like how fluffy the yeasted donuts are at Dough but I just love the variety of flavors + fillings at Doughnut Plant, especially the creme brulee and the tres leches donut. Plus for me cake donuts >>>

    And agree about Shake Shack and Dominique Ansel. A good Shake Shack is great but I’ve had a lot of pretty disappointing ones, for the $$$ I’d probably take In-N-Out over Shake Shack. And we made my little sister stand in line for the cronut at 7 am the day we were getting into NYC and then I was kind of disappointed over it/felt bad for making her stand in line…but that’s what little siblings are for no? :P

  9. Good Heavens no wonder your tummy is glad to be home. BUT it sounds like awesome fun.

  10. Abby says:

    Oh man, all of these spots look incredible, Stephanie! That ice cream… those fries… love!


  12. Marisa says:

    What burger do you recommend at Shake Shack? And out of all the places you visited, what were the absolute highlights?!

  13. Boskita says:

    Great post! Will be going to NYC in October! Thanks for the insight.

  14. Wow! I need to bookmark this for future trips to NYC. I have never been, but this has me itching to plan a trip.

  15. Oh wow, I’m getting such a heavy whiff of nostalgia here! Can’t wait to visit NYC again!
    Even though I never tried many of the places you mentioned, I totally second Victory Garden and Smorgasburg! I mean, goat milk soft serve! eeeee!! Back when I had the chance to try it I had honey lavender, and it was incredible (and I don’t even like lavender). I am so curious about trying something Ansel! I don’t expect it to be mind-blowing. Kinda on the same line, I was also a little let down when I tried Bouchon…though the almond croissant was super, the other two things I got were quite average. Next time, try Two Little Red Hens, and french toast at Sarabeth’s!
    Your reviews are an awesome read!

  16. Alexandra says:

    Oh my – you sure know how to have a good time! Shake Shack definitely reigns supreme :)

  17. Alana says:

    I’ve been waiting for this post and all I can say is YAYYY and THANK YOU. I’m def hitting up Chalait and Victory Garden in a couple weeks!! EEEP. :D :D :D

  18. this made me PAINFULLY hungry steph!!! i’ve never had shake shack … oh boy … goat milk halvah soft serve sounds insane in the membrane… xoxo

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *