The Ultimate Cheeseburger: the Juicy Lucy Burger

Posted May 16, 2018 by Stephanie
Make the ultimate burger: the juicy lucy. Juicy beef patty stuffed with melty gooey cheese. #burger #recipe #easy #dinner

Juicy Lucy Burger Recipe - Juicy Lucy Burger Recipe -

Juicy Lucy Burger Recipe - Juicy Lucy Burger Recipe -

It’s burger season! Time to break out the grill or cast iron pan, if that’s what you make your burgers in, and get your burger on. If you’re doing burgers I hope you get a chance to make a Juicy Lucy. I first heard about the infamous Juicy Lucy a couple of years ago. I was headed to Minneapolis for a quick trip and before I flew out, Mike did a quick search on what kind of foods Minneapolis is known for. The thing that came up again and again was a Juicy Lucy.

Juicy Lucy Burger Recipe -

Juicy Lucy Burger Recipe -

According to lore, Juicy Lucys (Lucies?) were invented in the city in the 50s in two different bars independently of each other. I think there’s some sort of Juicy Lucy rivalry going on between the two, but regardless, they both make a burger where the cheese is inside the patty instead of on top. The cheese makes everything extra juicy, thus Juicy Lucy.

Juicy Lucy Burger Recipe -

Of course, after Mike discovered Juicy Lucys, I got really excited. I mean, a burger with the cheese inside the patty? I could just imagine how gooey and melty and cheese pull friendly it was going to be. We watched a bunch of YouTube videos on them – the most notably weird one being of Richard Blais making a Juicy Lucy where the cheese wasn’t even melted. That led us down a Richard Blais YouTube hole. Did you know he calls his fans “Blaisians?!” Shudder.

Anyway, the most important part of a Juicy Lucy is the molten cheese core. To get that you have to cook your burger on the stove to get that nice seared crust, then finish it in the oven so that the cheese gets extra melty. I think I put a bit too much cheese in mine though because the cheese started to ooze out a bit. I’m not complaining though because the patty ended up with a cheese crust and crusty, crispy cheese is always a good thing.

Happy burger-ing! Hope you get some Juicy Lucys soon.

PS – I never did get a chance to try a Juicy Lucy in Minneapolis. Have you ever had one? We’ll have to go back one day!

Juicy Lucy Burger Recipe -

Juicy Lucy Burger Recipe
makes 1 burger, scale as needed

  • 1/4 lb ground chuck/beef
  • 1/4 cup shredded cheddar
  • salt and freshly ground pepper
  • toasted burger bun
  • ketchup, mayo, and mustard, to taste
  • 1-2 leaves green leaf lettuce, torn
  • 1-2 slices tomato
  • pickles, if desired

Heat the oven to 400°F.

Divide the beef into roughly 1/3 and 2/3 portions. Shape the 2/3 portion into a burger shape with an indent in the middle. Try to make the burger slightly bigger than your bun as it will shrink while cooking. Put the cheese in the center, top with the remaining beef and shape compactly into a burger patty. Season both sides with salt and pepper.

Heat a cast iron pan over medium-high and add a touch of oil. When hot, add the burger, and fry for 3-4 minutes on each side, until charred and a crust starts to form. The cheese should start to ooze out. Place the patty in the oven while you toast your bun a prepare your burger.

Lightly toast your bun and spread ketchup, mayo, and mustard, to taste, on the bottom bun. Top with the burger, lettuce, tomato, and the top bun. Enjoy immediately!


  1. Oh! That looks so so delicious. The patty looks so juicy… DREAMY!

  2. Love the juicy lucy! I have had a few growing up near Minneapolis. From the looks of this burger, I’d say you’re pretty close to the real thing ;) xo

  3. WK says:

    Matt’s Bar has the best Juicy Lucy. I’ve had both “originals”. The other bar that shall remain nameless serves them too dry.

  4. Amanda says:

    Totally agree with WK above. Matt’s Jucy Lucy (yep no i in their spelling!) is the best. It is more of a smash burger though. American in between with thin burgers – not smashed so the cheese doesn’t get out but not a thick burger. They say Fear the Cheese and its true! Hot molten cheese can come spraying out. Treat it like a soup dumpling. Have a little nibble and let the steam out!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *