chocolate chip cookie reviews review travel

Chocolate Chip Cookie Review: Chip, NYC

Are the line ups worth it?
Posted February 24, 2020 by Stephanie

Bakery: Chip
Date Eaten: 11/6/19
Cost: $3.50
Chip has been all over the internet with it’s crazy fun flavors (blueberry cheesecake, nutella sea salt, oatmeal apple pie) and crazy out the door line ups. They’re Queen’s answer to Manhattan’s Levain and they didn’t come to play. Huge scone like perfectly cookie scooped cookies that look like they didn’t change their shape at all in the oven. Super tall, I’m talking almost 1 inch in height and about 3.5 inches all around. There were a bunch of chocolate chips and they were large, but definitely chocolate chips and not chopped chocolate, chunks, disks or feves. A very light cookie with just a few small cracks. All the cookies at Chip are served warm and it’s definitely how they should be eaten. The edges were crisp but the inside was a touch too dry but also kind of melty. If you like shortbread, this is a good cookie for you, but it’s also kind of one note and sweet. I thought it would be gooey-er on the inside so maybe I just got a bunk one? All in all, this was a disappointing cookie :(

Edge: 2.5
Middle: 2
Chocolate: 2.5
Cookie: 2.5
Taste: 2.5
Total: 12/25

Follow along as I search for the world’s best chocolate chip cookie: methodology, what makes a good cookie, and a list of all the cookies I’ve eaten, right here.

Chip NYC's famous Chocolate Chip Cookie | www.iamafoodblog.com

Chip NYC’s famous Chocolate Chip Cookie | www.iamafoodblog.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *